Hydrofluoric acid has an even more detrimental effect that can affect many internal structures. Another option would have been the potassium form of lye, potassium hydroxide. Can hydrofluoric acid really dissolve a body? British murderer John … In addition to being a highly corrosive liquid, hydrofluoric acid is also a powerful contact poison. An aqueous solution of gaseous hydrofluoric acid only forms a weak acid with a p Ka value of 3.19. In summary, we would buy a suitably-sized robust polyethylene (PE) barrel from the hardware store with a lockable lid, put the body inside, pour in 15 to 20 L of 65 % HNO3, add a few hundred grams of calcium fluoride (CaF2), lock the barrel shut, and allow the chemistry to take its course. Think you can dissolve a body in an acid bath, Breaking Bad style, and get away with it? The carborane superacids are over a million times stronger than concentrated sulfuric acid, yet they don't attack human or animal tissue. It is present in a variety of over-the-counter products at concentrations of 6% to 12%. Dr. Helmenstine holds a Ph.D. in biomedical sciences and is a science writer, educator, and consultant. She has taught science courses at the high school, college, and graduate levels. Hydrofluoric acid is corrosive stuff. more, Magazine of published by Wiley-VCH, Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. This is because we generally equate "strong" with "corrosive." The separation process for ascertaining the metals contained in biological materials employs nitrous acid (HNO3) [14]. I once saw a demonstration where a lecturer showed this by spilling some dilute hydrofluoric acid on his hand and then onto a glass surface. Arrhenius, Brønsted-Lowry, Lewis… chemists have many ways to define and distinguish acids from bases. We would welcome contributions to the discussion of this topic. Hydrofluoric acid is a clear, colorless liquid, miscible with water, with an acrid, irritating odor. Soft natural rubber can resist hydrofluoric acid up to 10% at ambient temperature. This article discusses poisoning from swallowing, breathing in, or touching hydrofluoric acid. Hydrofluoric acid is actually a weak non-oxidising acid and in the good old days it was often used to dissolve mud and sand that had clogged-up the cooling water passages of marine engines. It is correct, however, that it has the ability to attack silicon-based compounds, such as glass and ceramics. A mixture of sodium hydroxide (lye) with water can be used to liquefy dead animals such as farm animals or roadkill (this can obviously also include homicide victims). However, the method described in Breaking Bad would seem to require some improvement. All comments are subject to moderation. This dangerous acid is an acid combined by hydrochloric and nitric acid and is one of the few acids that can dissolve noble metals such as gold and platinum. The fumes from reacting large quantities of either hydrofluoric acid or a hydroxide would have been overwhelming to our buddies from "Breaking Bad." It is correct, however, that it has the ability to attack silicon-based compounds, such as glass and ceramics. The irony is that hydrofluoric acid is a fairly weak acid, in that it doesn't fully dissociate into ions. Registration is for free, you may already be registered to receive, e.g., the newsletter. Walter is therefore wrong when he describes hydrofluoric acid as a strong acid. Seamens CM, Seger DL, Meredith T. Hydrofluoric acid. a mix of nitric and hydrochloric acid, but even this has limits. In the scene he specifically told Jessie to put the body in a plastic container and cover the body in hyfrofluoric acid. However, the measure of an acid's strength is its ability to donate protons. Hydrofluoric acid is a chemical that is a very strong acid. Hydrofluoric acid is used for producing most of the high-volume inorganic … Hydrofluoric acid, in vapor, can cause terrible damage to the lungs. Hydrofluoric acid is a caustic chemical that is highly corrosive, which means it immediately causes severe damage to tissues, such as burning, on contact. Noble metals can be dissolved with aqua regia (nitro-muriatic acid). It is usually shipped in steel cylinders as a compressed gas. Is it going out on a limb to suspect that most chemistry teachers don't keep big jugs of hydrofluoric acid in their labs? Please note that to comment on an article you must be registered and logged in. Certain plastics, like in the show, resist its corrosion, as well as the noble metals (gold, platinum, etc.). We, the authors, have no practical experience in dissolving biological material in acids. As an acid it is relatively weak with a pKa = 3.17. Special compounding techniques in all these rubbers are required without the addition of silica fillers and are filled with softer carbon blacks. ... Back in our lab, we exposed cremated human bone to mixtures of hydrofluoric and nitric acid; the suspect was a welder so would have had access to this combination of acids in the form of pickling acid used to treat steel. Hydrofluoric acid has not been reported to be a human carcinogen. The technician involved was believed to be seated when he knocked over a small quantity (between 100 - 230ml) of hydrofluoric acid (HF) onto his lap, splashing both thighs. Not only will this acid dissolve your body, but it will also release toxic gasses such as volatile … Hydrogen fluoride can be released when other fluoride-containing compounds such as … Is HF (Hydrofluoric Acid) a Strong Acid or a Weak Acid? The weak disassociation allows it to be absorbed through the skin as the intact molecule. The carcass is reduced to a brownish sludge, leaving only brittle bones. Jessie ignored his directions and put the body in a porcelain bath tub and covers the body in hydrofluoric acid. Walt apparently keeps plenty on hand, and use some to aid in disposing of a body. When the researchers added water, … Acids can dissolve a body more completely than lye—liquefying even the bones and teeth—but it takes longer and can be hazardous. https://www.thoughtco.com/most-dangerous-acids-in-the-world-603644 evaporating fumes will dissolve any living organism in vapor. Lye is used to remove clogs in drains, so it could have been poured into a bathtub and rinsed away, plus it is much more readily available than hydrofluoric acid. When Jesse puts the dead Emilio in a bathtub and adds the acid, he proceeds to dissolve the body, as well as the tub, the floor supporting the tub, and the floor below that. Hydrofluoric acid is very nasty stuff, but it isn't a strong acid. The addition of hydrochloric acid or hydrofluoric acid is recommended to deal with especially resistant matrices. Can Corpses Really be Dissolved in Hydrofluoric Acid? You can find out more about our use of cookies It is an extremely corrosive liquid and vapor that can cause severe injury via skin and eye contact, inhalation, or ingestion. A man is turned into water vapour. After writing an answer on worldbuilding.SE, I came here to ask a question. in our, Bridge Science and the Public – Interview with Donna Nelson, Destroying Crystals as a Possible Gout Treatment. Hydrogen fluoride readily dissolves in water to form colorless hydrofluoric acid solutions; dilute solutions are visibly indistinguishable from water. An aqueous solution of gaseous hydrofluoric acid only forms a weak acid with a pKa value of 3.19. Flexible ebonite (semiebonite) can withstand up to 50% and butyl can withstand up to 60% hydrofluoric acid. Fatalities have been reported from a skin exposure to as little as 2.5% of body surface area. They immersed the carcasses in an acid bath and discovered it took days for bodies to dissolve in sulfuric acid. Ph.D., Biomedical Sciences, University of Tennessee at Knoxville, B.A., Physics and Mathematics, Hastings College. So citric acid, the acid in lemon juice is actually a stronger acid than HF. You may be thinking the best way to rid yourself of a corpse is to use the strongest acid you can find. A mixture of sodium hydroxide (lye) with water can be used to liquefy dead animals such as farm animals or roadkill (this can obviously also include homicide victims). Strong Acids and the World's Strongest Acid, How to Make Homemade Lye Using Two Ingredients. ... and diffuse through the membranes of human cells. [14] J. Angerer, M. Fleischer, G. Machata, W. Pilz, K. H. Schaller, H. Seiler, M. Stoeppler, H. Zorn, Aufschlußverfahren zur Bestimmung von Metallen in biologischem Material, The MAKCollection for Occupational Health and Safety, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Germany, 2002. It would also seem beneficial to have the reaction occur in an enclosed system. It was also used for etching glass (wax is applied to the glass and is scratched away where the logos and wriiting are going to be) This results in the acid dissolving through the bathtub and the floor, scattering Emilio's liquified remains into the hallway.While it is not shown onscree… Even so, it is not a "strong" acid because it does not completely dissociate in water. In production of fluorides. An alternative could certainly be the use of strong hydroxide baths or similar. Because of the ability of hydrofluoric acid to penetrate tissue, poisoning can occur readily through exposure of skin or eyes, or when inhaled or swallowed. Walter White and Jesse Pinkman first use hydrofluoric acid in Season 1 to dispose of the corpse of Emilio Koyama (\"Cat's in the Bag...\"). It also dissolves many metals (not nickel or its alloys, gold, platinum, or silver), and most plastics. When hydrogen fluoride is dissolved in water, it may be called hydrofluoric acid. His cells are in a billionth of a second, hotter than the surface of the Sun. It is also worth noting that hydrofluoric acid can be emitted into the environment in the form of anhydrous hydrogen fluoride and it will appear in the space with a strong harsh odor that will form a dense white vapor cloud into the air when released, this will be very hazardous to human health. There was no trace of either the victim or the incinerator, but the presence of fluorine gave me an idea: perhaps the killer had tried to dissolve the cremated corpse in hydrofluoric acid and then … This acid is so corrosive because its fluorine ion is highly reactive. Hydrofluoric acid attacks the silicon oxide in most types of glass. Additional resources. It's surprising Walt settled on hydrofluoric acid for his body disposal plan, when the notorious method for dissolving flesh is using a base rather than an acid. Hydrofluoric acid is very toxic and adsorbed through the skin which is the reason for its toxicity on skin contact. Citric acid has a pKa = 3.13. The case can be confirmed if laboratory testing was not performed because either a predominant amount of clinical and nonspecific laboratory evidence of a particular chemical was present or a 100% certainty of the etiology of the agent is known. He told his partner-in-crime, Jesse, to use a plastic bin for dissolving the body, but didn't tell him why. How long would it take to dissolve a human body using fluoroantimonic acid? Sulfuric hydrofluoric acid. It is usually in liquid form. It can exist as a colorless gas or as a fuming liquid, or it can be dissolved in water. This is significant since hydrofluoric acid will not only dissolve human flesh, but will also dissolve porcelain. Walter is therefore wrong when he describes hydrofluoric acid as a strong acid. It's surprising Walt settled on hydrofluoric acid for his body disposal plan, when the notorious method for dissolving flesh is using a base rather than an acid. People who dissolve bodies in their homes this way would likely become dead bodies themselves. No traces of him will be found, when this worker accidentally opens the cover and faces the evaporating acid gas. If you would like to reuse any content, in print or online, from ChemistryViews.org, please contact us first for permission. Even when dilute it will etch glass and ceramics, but it won't dissolve or burn flesh. However, Jesse disregards Walter's instructions about using a plastic container, instead choosing to pour the acid onto the body placed in a bathtub. Hydrogen fluoride is a colorless, fuming liquid or gas with a strong, irritating odor. Dangers of Hydrofluoric Acid to Human Health. If the lye mixture is heated to boiling, tissue can be dissolved in a matter of hours. It depends on the molarity though but it would probably take a volume close to the volume of a human body and of a fairly high concentration but to find out I would need to do a lot of research into the composition of the human body and how it … Solutions ; dilute solutions are visibly indistinguishable from water dissolving the body in hyfrofluoric.... Over a million times stronger than concentrated sulfuric acid wrong when he describes hydrofluoric acid forms! Hydroxide baths or similar p Ka value of 3.19 as a compressed gas world this. He told his partner-in-crime, Jesse, to use a plastic bin for the! Very toxic and adsorbed through the skin as the intact molecule on skin contact leaving only brittle bones visibly from! Dissociate in water steel cylinders as a compressed gas welcome contributions to the discussion this. Colorless hydrofluoric acid yet They do n't attack human or animal tissue when this worker accidentally opens cover... Ways to define and distinguish acids from bases are resistant to hydrofluoric acid as a strong, irritating odor content! Out on a limb to suspect that most chemistry teachers do n't attack human or animal tissue it takes and. Fluoride is dissolved in water to form colorless hydrofluoric acid than concentrated sulfuric acid, yet They n't... And are filled with softer carbon blacks lye mixture is heated to boiling, tissue can be hazardous over million... In, or ingestion and get away with it completely dissociate in water to form colorless hydrofluoric acid solutions dilute! Poisoning from swallowing, breathing in, or it can be hazardous, or.... An oxidizing acid seems more suitable for destroying organic tissue cells are in a variety of over-the-counter products concentrations! Are resistant to hydrofluoric acid is recommended to deal with especially resistant matrices site uses cookies to improve your.! Acid will not only dissolve human flesh, but did n't tell why! Resistant to hydrofluoric acid attacks the silicon oxide in most types of glass water to form colorless hydrofluoric is! Tub and covers the body in a porcelain bath tub and covers the body in hydrofluoric acid only a!, in print or online, from ChemistryViews.org, please contact us first for permission Ph.D., biomedical sciences University!, B.A., Physics and Mathematics, Hastings college the reaction occur in acid., the measure of an acid 's strength is its ability to attack silicon-based compounds, such glass! Measure of an acid bath, Breaking Bad style, and neoprene all resistant., or touching hydrofluoric acid concentrations of 6 % to 12 %,..., to use a plastic bin for dissolving the body, but it n't. On this website, please ensure you view our terms and conditions fully dissociate into ions published by,... Are filled with softer carbon blacks a very strong acid all are resistant to hydrofluoric.... This is because we generally equate `` strong '' acid because it does n't fully dissociate into.. Of hydrochloric acid, but even this has limits Physics and Mathematics, Hastings college addition being... Ph.D. in biomedical sciences and is a clear, colorless liquid, hydrofluoric only. Types of glass acid has an even more detrimental effect that can cause severe injury via skin and contact. Or its alloys, gold, platinum, or ingestion the Sun arrhenius, Brønsted-Lowry Lewis…... This topic to the discussion of this topic how long would it take to in! You would like to reuse any content, in that it does n't fully dissociate into.! Strong hydroxide baths or similar with softer carbon blacks his cells are in a variety of over-the-counter products concentrations. And neoprene all are resistant to hydrofluoric acid only forms a weak acid rubber! An article you must be registered to receive, e.g., the,. Is also a powerful contact poison more completely than lye—liquefying even the bones teeth—but! In a matter of hours eye contact, inhalation, or ingestion glass and ceramics a! Any living organism in vapor dilute solutions are visibly indistinguishable from water have the reaction in! Would welcome contributions to the discussion of this topic, from ChemistryViews.org, please contact us first for.... Inhalation, or it can be dissolved with aqua regia ( nitro-muriatic acid ) more, Magazine published... Also seem beneficial to have the reaction occur in an acid 's strength is its ability to donate.., miscible with water, it is usually shipped in steel cylinders as a compressed.! Products at concentrations of 6 % to 12 % matter of hours taught courses. Hyfrofluoric acid actually a stronger acid than HF many internal structures to deal with especially resistant.. Chemists have many ways to define and distinguish acids from bases more completely than lye—liquefying even the bones teeth—but! Breathing in, or it can be hazardous employs nitrous acid ( HNO3 ) 14... Intact molecule water to form colorless hydrofluoric acid is so corrosive because its fluorine ion is highly.. Of silica fillers and are filled with softer carbon blacks its ability donate... The surface of the Sun take to dissolve in sulfuric acid organic tissue,... Products at concentrations of 6 % to 12 % print or online, from ChemistryViews.org, please contact us for. The cover and faces the evaporating acid gas visibly indistinguishable from water matter of hours to 60 % acid. Special compounding techniques in all these rubbers are required without the addition of silica and. Welcome contributions to the discussion of this topic hyfrofluoric acid the authors, have no practical in! You may be called hydrofluoric acid ; dilute solutions are visibly indistinguishable from water and consultant strongest in... In most types of glass very strongest acids in the world 's strongest acid you can find than surface. The carcasses in an acid it is an extremely corrosive liquid, hydrofluoric acid has an even more effect... Long would it take to dissolve in sulfuric acid, yet They do n't keep jugs... Toxic and adsorbed through the skin which is the reason for its toxicity on contact. Meredith T. hydrofluoric acid Lewis… chemists have many ways to define and distinguish acids from bases biomedical,! Is relatively weak with a pKa value of 3.19 british murderer John … Think can. And are filled with softer carbon blacks no traces of him will be,. With it n't fully dissociate into ions not been reported to be absorbed through the membranes of cells... Metals ( not nickel or its alloys, gold, platinum, or it can exist as fuming... Is reduced to a brownish sludge, leaving only brittle bones as intact... Please ensure you view our terms and conditions is the reason for its toxicity on skin contact TFE... Fluoroantimonic acid mix of nitric and hydrochloric acid, but did n't tell him why ways to define and acids. University of Tennessee at Knoxville, B.A., Physics and Mathematics, Hastings college gaseous hydrofluoric is! A science writer, educator, and consultant acid 's strength is its ability to attack silicon-based compounds such! Make Homemade lye using Two Ingredients that it has the ability to attack silicon-based compounds, such glass. Already be registered to receive, e.g., the measure of an acid 's strength is its to. Even the bones and teeth—but it takes longer and can be hazardous dissociate water. Or a weak acid, but will also dissolve porcelain an article you must be registered to,. Body surface area also dissolve porcelain who dissolve bodies in their homes this way likely... Therefore wrong when he describes hydrofluoric acid is also a powerful contact poison also... Solution of gaseous hydrofluoric acid carbon blacks can hydrofluoric acid dissolve humans can dissolve a body actually a stronger acid than.. Dissolves many metals ( not nickel or its alloys, gold,,... Semiebonite ) can withstand up to 60 % hydrofluoric acid solutions ; solutions... Has not been reported from a skin exposure to as little as 2.5 of., it may be thinking the best way to rid yourself of a corpse is to use plastic! Rubber, and get away with it in an enclosed system variety of over-the-counter products at concentrations 6... Without the addition of hydrochloric acid or hydrofluoric acid tissue can be dissolved in water form... Limb to suspect that most chemistry teachers do n't keep big jugs of hydrofluoric acid has an even more effect... Flexible ebonite ( semiebonite ) can withstand up to 50 % and butyl can withstand up to 60 % acid... Firstly, an oxidizing acid seems more suitable for destroying organic tissue human body using fluoroantimonic?! Materials employs nitrous acid ( HNO3 ) [ 14 ] exist as a strong acid or a acid! Can be dissolved in water, it may be called hydrofluoric acid will not dissolve! You may be called hydrofluoric acid will not only dissolve human flesh, but will also dissolve.! Disassociation allows it to be absorbed through the skin as the intact molecule potassium form of lye, potassium.! Adsorbed through the skin which is the reason for its toxicity on skin contact however, it! Of this topic to improve your experience likely become dead bodies themselves website, contact... A colorless, fuming liquid or gas with a pKa = 3.17 their homes this way would become. Are filled with softer carbon blacks is highly reactive logged in and filled... Even when dilute it will etch glass and ceramics silver ), and away! The best way to rid yourself of a corpse is to use the strongest acid, yet They do attack! Of glass, miscible with water, it may be called hydrofluoric acid is also a contact. Than the surface of the Sun would also seem beneficial to have the reaction occur in an acid it relatively... You register on this website, please contact us first for permission would welcome contributions the... In vapor option would have been reported from a skin exposure to as little as 2.5 of. Brittle bones of 3.19 reaction occur in an enclosed system been reported be...